In Third Grade, we love reading and sharing our thinking! Our blog is a great place for book club discussions. We can share our talking points and write comments to each other!
Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Goble/Stone Fox Book Club
Post your 2 Talking Points for your group members. Read through your group members' talking points and comment on 2 of them.
I feel like the way I felt about Stone Fox changed a lot as I read the book. At first, I thought he was scary and mean, but a the end my feelings changed. I realized that he was thoughtful. What do you guys think?
Grace, I agree. I always get a tear in my eye when I read the end of Stone Fox. I think it shows how much Searchlight loves Little Willy. I think he knew how important the race was even though he is a dog. What do you think?
Ava our book is about a little boy named Little Willy and his grandfather gets SUPER sick. Little Willy uses his college money to enter a snow dog race with his dog Search Light. I am not going to tell you the rest if he wins or not
I felt very bad about Searchlite I can not believe his heart burst. I loved the rest of the book except the part where he almost loses his farm and when his grandfather gets sick and then he finds him standing up in his room telling him to go on with the race he was so far ahead he dies. i couldn't beleive it
that is so nice to do that but you probaly would take that back because at the end the dogs heart burst when he ewas like 5 or 10 miles awat from the finish line!!! It was so sad at the end but happy in the beginning
serena stonefox isnNOTa real fox! IT Is a good book BUT, serena do you wish you were in the book? Becase I am in stonefox group you can wish to be in the group!
Did you think it was sad when his heart burst because I felt very sad?
ReplyDeleteIt broke my heart I started to cry
Deletewhy is the race 5 miles and why dose Stone Fox always win the races????
ReplyDeleteI FEEL LIKE i was in the book when he said five hundred dollars.
ReplyDeleteI feel like the way I felt about Stone Fox changed a lot as I read the book. At first, I thought he was scary and mean, but a the end my feelings changed. I realized that he was thoughtful. What do you guys think?
ReplyDeleteGrace, I agree. I always get a tear in my eye when I read the end of Stone Fox. I think it shows how much Searchlight loves Little Willy. I think he knew how important the race was even though he is a dog. What do you think?
ReplyDeleteGrace, StoneFox always wins because he is really good.
ReplyDeleteThat is sad that Searchlight dies. Do you agree?
ReplyDeleteGrace MissGoble, I feel the same way abot Serchlight I almost died myself I thought It was so Depressing.I was so sad.
ReplyDeleteI couldn't believe searchlight died
ReplyDeleteI wonder what the crowd was thinking when Searchlight fell on the snow? What were you thinking?
ReplyDeleteGrace,I was so sad when i read the part when Searchlight's heart burst were you sad
ReplyDeleteMiss Goble thank you for egreeing with me
ReplyDeleteyes Meta i was
ReplyDeleteI THINK THIS BOOK DESERVES 5 STARS!!!!
ReplyDeleteI LOVE THIS BOOK.I WISH i WAS IN it.
ReplyDeleteDenise i felt the same way, isn't that a lot of money?
ReplyDeleteDenise & Grace i feel the same way it would be so cool to have a charter like us and the charter would have the same name
ReplyDeleteMiss Goble that is right our feelings changed throughout the story!!!
ReplyDeleteStoneFox stands up for him
ReplyDeleteHow nice of StoneFox
ReplyDeleteI agree Grace My feelings changed throught the story
ReplyDeleteMy eyes got watery when i was reading the last chapter of Stone Fox. Grace told me she felt the same way.
ReplyDeletewhat is your book about?
ReplyDeleteyes i know ben how nice of stone fox
ReplyDeleteAva our book is about a little boy named Little Willy and his grandfather gets SUPER sick. Little Willy uses his college money to enter a snow dog race with his dog Search Light. I am not going to tell you the rest if he wins or not
ReplyDeleteIs this a good book sould i read it?
ReplyDeleteYou would love this book you said you love animals This book is just right for you
ReplyDeleteMelonie do you wish to be in ston fox?
ReplyDeleteIt depends on if it is good or not. Denise is it good?
ReplyDeletecamille it is a good book to me
ReplyDeleteyes it, is good.But how is your book?
ReplyDeleteWhat is Stone Fox about?
ReplyDeleteI felt very bad about Searchlite I can not believe his heart burst. I loved the rest of the book except the part where he almost loses his farm and when his grandfather gets sick and then he finds him standing up in his room telling him to go on with the race he was so far ahead he dies. i couldn't beleive it
ReplyDeleteMeta do you love the book.I do.
ReplyDeleteStone Fox is about a little boy named Willy his Grandfather got sick and then he wants to die i will tell you in PERSON!!!!
ReplyDeleteAhhhhhhh!!! Why?
ReplyDeleteMeta do you like the book or not
ReplyDeleteJoseph would you rather read Stone Fox or Homer Price?????
ReplyDeletedoes someone die
ReplyDeleteI'm not so sure...
ReplyDeleteGrace are you sure you want to talk about stone fox?
ReplyDeleteyes if i was president than i would pernounce that that is my 2nd favorite book in the whole world!!!!
ReplyDeletewhy doesnt anybody answer me!!!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDeletewho cares?
ReplyDeletewhat did you mean everybody answers you even in basketball and someone dose die and it is the dog Searchlight
ReplyDeleteI wish i was in stone fox group
ReplyDeletemiss.goble I wonder if stone fox is a real fox.
ReplyDeletewhy do you want to be in the stone fox group?
ReplyDeletethat is so nice to do that but you probaly would take that back because at the end the dogs heart burst when he ewas like 5 or 10 miles awat from the finish line!!! It was so sad at the end but happy in the beginning
ReplyDelete100 feet not 5 or 10 miles away from the finish line when his heart burst
ReplyDeleteThis book is really good what do you think?????
ReplyDeleteHa meta i think that book is good
ReplyDeletei thought that the book was good meta
ReplyDeleteit was nice that stonefox pulled sherchlight the next 10 milles to the fineshline
ReplyDeleteserena stonefox isnNOTa real fox! IT Is a good book BUT, serena do you wish you were in the book? Becase I am in stonefox group you can wish to be in the group!
ReplyDeletei think it needs more stars thann 5 but it only goes to 5
ReplyDeleteyes it is not a real fox but you can always use your imaginnation once in a while!!!
ReplyDeleteI wondered if grandpa will die?
ReplyDeleteI loved that book it was really sad.
ReplyDelete