In Third Grade, we love reading and sharing our thinking! Our blog is a great place for book club discussions. We can share our talking points and write comments to each other!
Wednesday, April 20, 2011
Rozzell/Shiloh Book Club
Post your 2 Talking Points for your group members to comment on. Read through your group members' talking points and comment on 2 of of your group members' talking points.
here are my talking points for book club i wounder why marty's dad said yes to keeping Shiloh and not before? how did he survive after ch. 11 because a German Shepherd hurt Shiloh's ear and leg?
here are my 2 talking points for book club. Can you belive that shiloh is still alive? shiloh's leg must be very bad because he has to get 20 to 30 stitches.
Jack i have a text to self connection not the same thing as Shilo but it is that serchlight when they were 5 feet away from the finish line his heart burst but that was my text to self connection
here are my talking points for book club
ReplyDeletei wounder why marty's dad said yes to keeping Shiloh and not before?
how did he survive after ch. 11 because a German Shepherd hurt Shiloh's ear and leg?
wuy dose martys dad like sshiloh now.
ReplyDeletehere are my 2 talking points for book club.
ReplyDeleteCan you belive that shiloh is still alive?
shiloh's leg must be very bad because he has to get 20 to 30 stitches.
Jack i have a text to self connection not the same thing as Shilo but it is that serchlight when they were 5 feet away from the finish line his heart burst but that was my text to self connection
ReplyDeleteJack i agree he must have got hurt bad to get that many stiches
ReplyDeletehere are my 2 talking points for book club
ReplyDeletepage 79 Shiloh died and page 80 is alive.
his foot most be bad thats sad.
what is shiloh about
ReplyDeleteJack and Lissy really agree about Shiloh
ReplyDeleteSo do I!
ReplyDeleteI think that Shiloh the book is sadness
ReplyDeleteis the book funny
ReplyDeleteHALEY YOU ASKED ABOUT FRINDLE ITS ABOUT A BOY WHO CALLS A PEN FRINDLE AND NOW ITS GETTING OUT OF CONTROL
ReplyDeleteNo it is not fuuny! Shiloh gets hrut.
ReplyDeleteis shilo a girl or boy
ReplyDeleteJack,
ReplyDeleteDo u like the book Shiloh do u think it would be a good book for me i heard it was really sad
Davis well be sad becaues shiloh gets hrut
ReplyDeletegood talking points haley
ReplyDeleteJack,
ReplyDeleteHow did he get hurt? Is he ok?
Will I like this book?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeletewhy is Judd shooting doe when it is not deer season. He is going to get in alot of trouble.
ReplyDeleteena,
ReplyDeleteshilo got hurt by a german sheperd
Do you like the book Jack?
ReplyDeletei wonder what the book is like. would it be a good book for me, wwould i like it?
ReplyDeletejanat,
ReplyDeletei heard you asked if shiloh was boy/girl i think hes a boy but i dont know for sure cause i havent read the book yet.